Cologne 1-0 Arsenal – player ratings

74

Arsenal topped their Europa League group in spite of a 1-0 defeat to Cologne at the RheinEnergieStadion tonight.

A second half penalty from Sehrou Guirassy gave the home side the victory, but the draw in the other game between Red Star Belgrade and BATE Borisov meant the Gunners won the group.

Here’s how the players rated.

DO
13
5.5
MD
2
5
PM
4
7
RH
16
6
CC
21
5.5
FC
34
4
ME
35
4.5
AMN
55
6.5
JW
10
5.5
DW
23
5
OG
12
4
DO
13
6
MD
2
6
PM
4
7
RH
16
6
CC
21
6
FC
34
5
ME
35
6
AMN
55
7
JW
10
6
DW
23
6
OG
12
5
45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

13: David Ospina

6
arseblog
5.5
Readers
36

Didn't have a lot to do but showed he's as good as Petr Cech when it comes to penalties

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

2: Mathieu Debuchy

6
arseblog
5
Readers
34

Did fine, clearly doesn't have the legs for wing-back, unlucky to concede the penalty as the bloke dive like Divey Magee.

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

4: Per Mertesacker

7
arseblog
7
Readers
3

Unflustered, great positioning and reading of the game needed

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

16: Rob Holding

6
arseblog
6
Readers
52

He was grand

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

21: Calum Chambers

6
arseblog
5.5
Readers
35

Looked like a man who hasn't played for some time, doesn't have the legs at the moment to offer a threat in that position

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

34: Francis Coquelin

5
arseblog
4
Readers
40

Dribbled the ball out of play at least three times. But also nearly scored, hitting the post with one effort. Not his finest night though.

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

35: Mohamed Elneny

6
arseblog
4.5
Readers
51

He's dependable, you know what you're going to get.

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

55: Ainsley Maitland-Niles

7
arseblog
6.5
Readers
56

Industrious and showed good skill at times, needs to work on his final ball though

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

10: Jack Wilshere

6
arseblog
5.5
Readers
9

Tried to make things happen, sometimes he tried a bit too hard. Things didn't happen

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

23: Danny Welbeck

6
arseblog
5
Readers
39

It was pre-planned for him to come off after 45 minutes. Wouldn't it have been better to put him on for 30 at the end?

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

12: Olivier Giroud

5
arseblog
4
Readers
29

Got little service but did little otherwise.

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

17: Alex Iwobi

6
arseblog
5
Readers
46

Added a bit of something when he came on but it wasn't enough something

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

61: Reiss Nelson

6
arseblog
6.5
Readers
59

Had one lovely dribble which resulted in a shot

45217
fc424681ab5e0303ea2fc62f3e597862
10.0.0.7

62: Eddie Nketiah

N/R
arseblog
5.5
Readers
63

On too late to rate and on too late to actually do anything

Vote is now closed.

Bonus rating: 10/10 - Jermaine Jenas saying he couldn't see Arsene Wenger making any half-time changes, moments before Alex Iwobi's introduction for Danny Welbeck was announced. Glorious.

Leave a Reply

74 Comments on "Cologne 1-0 Arsenal – player ratings"

avatar
newest oldest most voted
Stuart_Ten

You do know penalties are generally pretty hard to save, right?..

Runcorn Gooner

I reckon if Cech or Ospina stood still on the line they would save a couple of them

Giroud\'s scorpion kick
Giroud\'s scorpion kick

But if they stood still, you’d say why do they stay and do nothing. The endless river…

lee dicks on

No river is endless my friend.

Monkey knees

All rivers flows are endless….

dr Strange

No…..

karl

Tech never dives the right way, so why not try standing in the middle, or bring Seaman in to train him.

St Helens Gooner

I don’t usually agree with anyone from Runcorn because you’re all inbred, but I’ll give you a thumbs up for that 😀

David Hillier\'s luggage
David Hillier\'s luggage

Penalty takers will soon cotton on and just put them in the corner

Nordin

Its difficult for GK. If they stand in the centre and shot is to the sides, they cant save it either. Anw Ospina penalty saving record is much better than Cech. At least he has saved a few already for club and country

Martin

Not forgetting the countless errors he has made

A Different George

He was, in fact, brilliant on penalties for Chile against Argentina in the Copa America final. (Well, a lot of players missed or made it easy; no keeper can save a well-taken penalty.)

Drogheda gunner

Ospina is columbian

IamaGoober

Has anyone noticed that Cech always dives to his right, and the strikers always put it to his left.

And you know whats going to happen don’t you. The one time he dives to his left, the striker will put it to his right…

Canuck Gunner

Yes, but Cech’s record is rather appalling. Would have been great to see Ospina save it to show that at least one of our keepers can. I’m an amateur GK and have a 100% save record on Pk’s this season, so they are stoppable. Ok, so I have only faced the one pk this season – but it’s still a save.

Kartik Iyer

Both are rather quite good in open play…how many incredible saves has Cech made this season itself…the question is why do we concede so many of them(though this one was a figment of the referee’s imagination)

Third Plebeian

You do know we were playing the worst team in the Bundesliga, right?

And lost.

GraeB

We started with a midfield that included Elneny, Coq and Chambers – what creativity and pace was anyone expecting? It was like an AFC rehabilitation team with a couple of kids thrown in.

If AW was serious about the game, he’d at least have gone for two wingers. The remaining game will probably bring an even stranger format.

ronaldo

yeah, but when the draw was made a lot of people on here said how good they were, even though they were at the bottom of the league

Stuart_Ten

Well done, Sherlock.

Xxxrob

I would stand in the middle every time. Law of averages someone will eventually shoot there and you’ll save it

V h

Wilshere needlessly gave the ball away dozens of times. He just isn’t up to Arsenal standard

Scooby doobie

Just like Sanchez does week in and week out.

BODMAS

and Sanchez with more end products and assists and less injury prone or imparted

Indian Gooner

Alright, things didn’t come off that well for Wilshere at times today(although for me, he was the only one trying out something.) but the thing is.. you just don’t say that about Jack Wilshere. Please.

V h

Why, if Ramsey or Xhaka played that terrible everyone here would be saying they should never play for the club again.

I’d rather have Reiss playing and getting better vs. allowing Jack to take up a spot on the bench when he just isn’t good enough.

Wenger out this, F Rambo that, Ozil is a luxury…. BUT our #10 shirt gets an unlimited pass? COME ON!

Danny

Taxi’s on its way mate…

PFo

Except he was excellent in several other Europa games so far. So how do you square that with “he just isn’t good enough”? It’s almost as if you shouldn’t make absolute statements about a player’s quality based on one performance…

Kwame Ampadu Down

‘It’s almost as if you shouldn’t make absolute statements about a player’s quality based on one performance…’

Unless It’s after a brilliant Totts derby performance – then you can 100% say without amy doubt how brilliant some players are based on one performance?

Cannonball

“Why, if Ramsey or Xhaka played that terrible everyone here would be saying they should never play for the club again.”

No.. This is not facebook. Arseblog forum members have class. Unlike you.

Bould\'s Eyeliner

But we do say that.

Samgunz

I’ll get your co

Jimbo Jones

You’re bloody right though mate.

Wilshere is massively overrated. He’s only ever played well for England

Martin

Memory transplant needed

BigArse

Granted, he’s not there right now but has shown early in his career that he was up to that standard, and some flashes this season. He got injured over and over in an Arsenal shirt so I’m happy to stand by him and give him a chance to get that top form back. Do we re-sign him? I have no idea. I think it depends on his performances going forward.

Damsel

Really can’t see what others see in him. His only advantage is, he is homegrown. Had one good game against Barcelona. Can understand why he got little game time on loan last year. Definitely not Arsenal class!!!!

Martin

Played virtually the whole season for Bournemouth last season and was clearly their best player. Please get your facts right. Before his injuries he was an England regular and was Motm sevearal times for them. Had many great matches too for Arsenal. You have a selective memory.

Drogheda gunner

No he wasnt one of there best players last year.he was playing att midfield had no goals no assists.how do you make him out to be there best player?

Drogheda gunner

I agree he takes way to much out of the ball

BergerToe

The one plus was Maitland-Niles, that little turn over the defender who then got booked was delicious.

A Different George

He looked very good , especially in the first half, but I couln’t tell if it was just that the Koln defender was so slow–Maitland-Niles just ran past him and turned him at will.

Maniac

Meh.

Andy

My brother joked that Debuchy would score 2 goals for Koln today. Really wasn’t far from the truth. He turned over the ball to give koln their only real chance on goal and then made that needless challenge. Sure it was a dive, but he had coverage and was forcing the play wide. Anyone who knows footie will tell you, if you touch a player heading out of bounds in the penalty box they’re gunna go down. Debuchy’s decision making is sh*t. He goes down playing injured much too often for a defender and really can’t get forward, period. Has zero presence in the air. It makes sense that we cannot sell him. He is awful. Not really understanding how people rate him anything other 1-2. His only real contributions were conceding a penalty and dishing up a shot on goal for koln. :/

Fireman Sam

I always thought Debuchy was pretty good. Especially before Arnautovic pushed him into the hoardings.

Sounds like he had a mare tonight though

lessthanthesumoftheirparts
lessthanthesumoftheirparts

Thought Elneny ‘s deleivery and all-round game was especially poor this evening.

Gooner57

His corners were seriously bad, I don’t remember any beating the first man. When you have the likes of Giroud and Per in the box it’s such a waste.

lee dicks on

I agree, was bordering on lazy at times. If that’s an audition to get back into the first 11..

Cechmate

Tell me about it! I was so frustrated whenever I saw him taking the dead ball delivery. He has the heart but not the skill, he just keeps making sideways passes and then you pair him with Coq, who is a terrible passer himself and then wonder why we don’t deliver breakthrough passes against a team that is sitting deep! In fact Koln moved the ball upstream faster than us during counter attacks!

We didn’t have players who could run behind the defence and we didn’t have players who could deliver crosses and corners, so we were expecting individual brilliance to get us a goal, the chances of which are less without someone like Sanchez on pitch – though OG too does at times.

While Iwobi does very well for his country I don’t think he’s any better than a Joel Campbell for us and AW relying on him isn’t going to bring him results today or in next couple of years. To me, he looks like he’s following Wilshere’s growth trajectory which is worrying – i don’t think he’s improved from last year to now after a run-in with the senior folks. He would probably have one brilliant game in 8 matches but not up there still in terms of consistency.

But Giroud was the most disappointing, he didn’t try enough and he was having a private party with Wilshere – both trying to lay the ball off for the other at the edge of the box with a bunch of defenders ahead of them. He had a great chance to score (though he was marginally offside) and missed connecting with the ball! As a senior member, he needs to read the game and guide the youngsters and tell them where & how he wants the ball delivered to score, particularly when you’re chasing the game.

Our away debacle continues this season and hope we do better than this we face an in-form Burnley away from home, though it’s a different team.

Ausdrexler

I just want to see an Arsenal GK stay in center of the goal.. I think they would have more chance of saving a penalty that way! I dont know the stats, but it seems a fair % of penalties go down the middle vs Arsenal so why not play the odds….. at moment they are saving 0% cant do any worse!

PodB

If only Nelson had scored from his mazy run … it would all be different.
Watched whole game, we were actually okay, but couldn’t score.
Wilshere not the best headers, but almost scored from range at end.
Move on to Burnley and Chris Wood the Kiwi colossus, who tk God may have a dodgy hammie ..

GraeB

Great run, great skill BUT why, oh why, don’t we force players to train until they are comfortable using both feet? If Nelson used his left foot he’d could have blasted it instead of right foot toe poke.

Get Santi in to show them all how to do it for their £20k-300k wages!

santori

If anyone needs reminding how much of a gulf there is between our first and second team selection…those idiotic voices calling for Granit to be replaced by the likes of Jack.

I like our reserve players and they have function in the first team but as a collective, this is a very different Arsenal squad from the last week so not all that surprising.

We were not sharp enough in front of goal and did not take the chances created.

On the plus side, several players had decent enough performances to warrant potential for first squad rotation needs.

Chief amongst them surprisingly AMN.

Such an unfancied player and one who has taken his opportunity no matter where they present themselves. He is now starting to also express himself making the wingback role on the left his own potential.

Remember we also have Cohen Bramall out on loan and potentially we may yet dip in market if there was no solution but the energetic display from Maitland Niles will certainly put him in contention as back up to Kolasinac come next summer.

Slightly quieter was Chambers but it was refreshing to see Wenger put him back into his natural position where he had first flourished with Soton.

I think it will be harsh to say he was anonymous because he is only coming back from a long lay off. For most parts, he was defensively sound and toward the end of his stay on the pitch, he started to get his timing right with his penetration down the right.

Metersecker and Holding were largely untroubled. A bit harsh to blame the penalty on Debuchy (it was very soft to say the least) and good for the Frenchman to have another overall decent run out with the team, even if his future with us likely less than more, we may yet need him this season.

I thought Coquelin had a mix bag. He had two very good attempts at goal but also a couple of inexplicable panic/miscontrols and several poor passes.

Elneny in that sense was a little more steady without offering much, it was another OK performance from an average player. HIs quality on corners leaves much to be desired.

Would have preferred Iwobi, on from the start. Very energetic coming on, kept the ball well for us and made things happened.

Jack also tried for us but somehow his link with Giroud when missing today and there were (in the end) too many attempts simply trying to slip through the middle (some of which almost pulled off it has to be said)

Welbeck provided a physical presence but his touch at times is still heavy, GIroud did not have one of his better games.

The introduction of Reiss (expected) brought almost full dividends ina wonderful solo run. Nketieh (also as expected) put on to salvage something and got close too but we can’t expect miracles every day.

In the end we paid for our lack of incisiveness in final application.

Next.

Banksy

I think Jack is only as good as the striker he has ahead of him as any attacking midfielder would be in regards to assists. Now Giroid just isnt showing enough right now. Pundits keep praising his hold up play but i fail to see it. Nothing sticks, attacks are breaking down once he gets involved. Enough is enough. Yes crossed were poor but he has been poor, he’s not even producing off the bench anymore.

Third Plebeian

You can put anyone in front of Jack right now. He wouldn’t find him. His first touch is still a tackle…or a throw-in for the opposition.

Drogheda gunner

Your obviously english

sixteen swans

Best to have a duff penalty in a game that doesn’t matter.

Still, we lost and won the group with a game to spare.

Only question remains … how many fans are going to turn up for that last group game?

Fireman Sam

I love losing yet winning even so

Safe Hands

I think a lot of the issues today stemmed from a lack of natural width from both fullbacks and wide attackers. If you haven’t got overlapping runners, preferably on the side that’s their strongest foot, then you’ll always find it difficult with a striker like Giroud (who needs the space that’s created for him). It also helps Jack. I think playing Nelson as the right forward would have seriously helped today.

Cliff Bastin

What a good hearted squad we have that knows Cologne were due a bit of joy.

Nelson

For like the first time ever I fell asleep and missed arsenal play, seems I was fortunate I didn’t miss much.

Looking at the team I’m not even slightly surprised though, lots of great players but other than giroud have any of them ever scored more than 5 in a season ?

Andres

Looking at the line up i see maybe 8 players that will probably leave or should leave this summer. Per is retiring, Jack wont get another contract, Giroud is probably regreting staying, Ospina likewise, Debuchy, Coquelin and Elneny aren’t good enough. I also have doubts about Chambers. The less i say about Walcott, even though he didn’t play, the better. Add Ozil and Alexis leaving on a free and we end up with the task of replacing a whole eleven between Janaury and next summer. Some youngsters can cover some positions which is better imho than hanging to the same old deadwood, but still the new transfer guy surely will have an inmense task ahead of him.

Mark

These matches have become really boring to watch unfortunately. Not a lot of creativity on the field with Elneny, Coquelin, Giroud and Chambers among others.

Hermitian

Funnily enough, we may have to get used to this: last night was a taster of life post Sanchez and Ozil.

I don’t buy these “second string” stories. Only the defense was makeshift last night. There’s also not a lot of difference in quality between a Xhaka-Ramsey and a Coq-Elneny midfield.
We also know that Lacazette won’t be playing every match for us.

With Ozil and Sanchez unavailable, last night’s team was as best a team as we could put out.

A Person

You are totally wrong , the team against Koln had 11 freaking changes , Ozil and Sanchez are just 2 players , nothing more ! we were great without them against Chelsea , so don’t make unnecessary drama.

Philip

We didn’t win the game, but we won the group and rested players.

The young gun on the left will eventually give players in the center a run for the money … if he isn’t already.

Keep calm and carry on!

Third Plebeian

Second string is garbage. This is what’s on offer should any of the first team get injured.

Carlos _ Santana

I thought Le coq was much I proved in this game.. Just didn’t have much cohesion but also giroud needed better service.. But least we’re top ?

lula

I’ve enjoyed these games but you know, with Ozil and Sanchez leaving and questions over Ramsey and possibly Welbeck, we have a lot of deadwood in the team. Sorry to say this but I’m thinking it’s less me being grumpy and more a hard truth.

Bai Blagoi

I must have watched a different game. For me Coq’s performance yesterday was his best since Santi’s times.

TeeCee

It’s entirely natural to think that your coq is more impressive than others think it is.

Laca-Sead

Coquelin was the best player on the pitch. He accelerated the game, change of play, recuperated the ball. yes he lost the ball on a couple of occasions but not with than anyone else on the night. With a bit of confidence and gas time I’ll play him from of Ramsey.

dee

wilshire is absolute beans
take a bag of bibs and cones in jan for him

SaintSanti

Coq’s numbers suggest he was quite all right, mostly defensively. He had Arsenals most tackles (three out of four, El Neny had one, same for Jack), two interceptions (only Mertesacker had five, no other midfielder had even one) and also won an aerial duel. Offensively, he had 98 passes (second only to Holding, same as El Neny), of which an immense 69 forward and 39 in the final third! Despite playing mostly forward and into the final third he had an pass succes rate of 92%. Yes, his dribbling looked awful but I don’t think he deserves that much worse than El Neny.

Gooner Sam

I think Elneny was poor and Iwobi disappointing when he came on. Shame I like him but he really needs to push on