Elneny ban overturned by the FA

63

Mohamed Elneny will be available for Arsenal’s next three games after the FA decided that he should not have been sent off against Southampton.

The Egypt international was given his marching orders in the final moments of the Gunners 3-2 win after making contact with the face of Cedric Soares. It looked harsh at the time, although a replay did confirm the contact.

Arsenal appear to have appealed the decision and won. Something of a surprise all things considered, but good news, especially given we’re pretty short of central midfield options at the moment.

A statement from the FA reads: “Mohamed Elneny will be available for Arsenal’s next three games after an Independent Regulatory Commission accepted that he was wrongly dismissed for violent conduct against Southampton on Sunday, April 8, 2018.”

guest
63 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Lord Bendnter

Thank you!!!

Runcorn Linnet

Justice. There were a number of incidents far worse than Elneny on Saturday that went unpunished. The Southampton player who gave Elneny a massive shove was more guilty of violent conduct.

Gooooonnnnnnaaaaaaa

Just imagining Mark Hughes’s face when he finds out about this, he’s probably still fuming about Wilshere deserving to be sent off!

Anonymarse

Mark Hughes’s face isn’t something I want to imagine

SizC

But what about his face when Southampton and Stoke get relagated. First manager to have a hand in two clubs getting relagated

Burn Baby Burn

Completely unexpected. Will you be re-writing today’s blog post?

Punter

Blogs, imagine everytime you have to rewrite when you get something wrong…haha.

   kaius

Blogs wrote that he thought the red was “too harsh” but the Match of the Day 2 programme showed another angle that clearly showed Elneny make contact the face. He wrote “that’s always going be a sending off if the officials spot it, which they did.”

He’s absolutely correct – English referees overreact to hand to face incidents. But as the FA have shown, not every hand to face incident is an automatic red. “Striking or hitting” is violent conduct. Pushing is not.

Maul Person

Well I’ll be…! Good news as I wasn’t expecting them to go against they’re precious referees!

Arse City Blues

Their always sticking up for they’re precious referees

Saint Arsenal

I see what you did they’re

Pedant

Their they’re, don’t get angry there.

Maul Person

Dare I say “oops”…!

Matt

If Arsenal do well in Europe it will help the national co-effient.
If you consider that you can kind of see why the FA have been generous for once

Ivan Drago

Aren’t the big leagues getting guaranteed European spots from next season, so the coefficients won’t matter?

euchan

maybe not for next year, but in long run it’s always better to have more coefficient, no?

One of them is lying!

Co-efficients r good!

David Hillier's luggage

A Premier League ban would have had no impact on Elneny’s European availability, and although it is good to keep the association coefficient up, with the rule changes from next season the top four associations will automatically have four teams in the Champions League group stages – England are currently second (way off Spain) and miles ahead of 5th place France. Our club coefficient is what we really need to maintain by winning in Europe to ensure good seedings. We should be around the top 10 for the start of next season, however we’ve only amassed about the same amount… Read more »

Copelandão

I thought they got rid of seedings in favour of league placement, or is that just for the top pot? Wouldn’t we be top pot regardless if we win the Europa League?

David Hillier's luggage

League placement is just for the top pot, so CL winners and the domestic champions of the 7 top ranked leagues occupy that. The rest (including Europa winners) are ordered via their club coefficient ranking. If (big if) we win the Europa, we would be in pot 2 alongside the likes of Atletico, Dortmund, Utd, either Porto/Benfica, Napoli and two of Real/Shakhtar/Basel depending on permutations. In addition, if we qualify it pretty much stops Sp*rs from getting into pot 2.

Also, it’s a 5 year cycle, so one bad can make a big dent.

goonerang

I don’t know why everyone’s so surprised to be honest. That decision was a howler. The incident deserved a yellow at worst. I would’ve been surprised had Arsenal not appealed it.

Maniac

Not surprised about the appeal made by Arsenal but the fact that the FA actually overturned the decision. They almost always stick with the referee’s decision.

A Different George

Well, remember the FA overturned the red card to Gabriel and banned Diego Costa instead–though Gabriel still got a one-match ban for his actions after he was shown the card. (So, everyone who criticised Jack for ushering Elneny away should apologize, even if Jack did start the whole thing.) Diego Costa and Mike Dean, the memory makes me shudder.

SantiSandler

By the rule book it was hardly a howler. Yes, I wouldn’t say it was “violent” but the bottom line is you can’t put your hands on the other guy’s face and that should be a zero tolerance rule. It was a stupid move from Elneny, he put himself where didn’t he belong and left himself completely open to the interpretation of the official.

Redbeard

I thought he was doing the right thing trying to stand over ball avoiding the quick fk. Something we’ve been told we are naive about in the past.

   kaius

“You can’t put your hands on the other guy’s face”

Absolute rubbish. Can we please stop parroting commentator-speak. Players pat each other (even opposition players) on the head or the cheek all the time. There’s no blanket ban against “raising your hands”.

Referees have to assess for foul or dangerous intent, and it’s not an automatic red if use of force was negligible. Commentators catch-phrases and the laws of the game are not the same thing!

Louisaag

Well said!

A Different George

But whether it was “violent” is in fact the only issue in this case.

Jasmeet

Thanks Allah

Dobbi

Thank you Spaghetti Monster

Auba ma Ying

Mocking other people’s beliefs… How classy.

Bergkamp 3:16

Common sense prevails. Thank Bergkamp!

Gus Caesar

I’m very surprised because he pushed the player in the face – i think we’d have been asking for a res card were it the other way around. Just goes to show how odd the FA is, completely unfathomable.

shokim

Excellent news. Not having Elneny to call on is just unthinkable imo, given our shortage in midfield. FA being lenient on Arsenal? Wonders never cease.

francis

Q

Mr media

Aha. He was only guilty of the lesser charge of arseholish behaviour rather than violent. Do we have favourite arseholish behaviour that we recall? Keown’s ‘bumping’ of Nistelroy for example?

rellends

What a surprise that is.

It'Sanogo-al

After reviewing the incident replay link, Jermaine Jenas is a smug little twerp

SharpasFc

Every time Jermaine is forced to talk about Arsenal in a good way, you can literally see him gritting his teeth…it’s hilarious!

Macca

A truly shocking outbreak of common sense by the FA.

Jordan

Bet even the FA surprises themselves sometimes.

Chrispy

Well fuck me. This doesn’t sit well with me at all considering where the FA sit on my ‘love to gate scale’

Michael Bolton Wanderers

Incredible. Must feel great for elneny

Lance Banner

What is this witchcraft? Arsenal get 3 penalties in two games and a red card overturned?

GraeB

Maybe the comments on here about the anti-Arsenal bias will have to stop for a while. Or is it just that we’re not in the fight for anything this year?

Chidi

Well I’ll be a monkey’s uncle ?

BigArse

Good. The worst thing he did was be taller than the other bloke.

TeeCee

FA allows Arsenal appeal.
Other news : Pope converts to Buddhism, sun fails to come up.

George

I. am. stunned.

Great news, just never expected the FA to do something so … sensible.

Shank

Well Ill be bollixed…………

Hi-brid

Astonishingly rare application of common sense when FA could so easily have hidden behind the letter of the law.

Cliff Bastin

He is, wait for it, not that kind of player.

A Different George

Well, 7amkickoff did, reluctantly, say that about him. First red in his career, averages 0.5 fouls per match.

cricketeer

good. now soton and their players can rot to championship league and forever become mugmasher’s feeder club.

arsepedant

Wow. I think I’ll go buy a lottery ticket now.

Lula

I am a little surprised by this. But I suppose if you sent everyone off for what Elneny did in that game, it’d have been abandoned. I still think he’s a bit lucky though. I was counting on it at all.

daniel

Ederson seemed to do exactly the same last night and just get yellow, so it would have been pretty unreasonable if elnenys red stood

A Different George

Ederson was a lot closer to violent conduct, though that was a UEFA match, not a Prem officiating team. On the other hand, that referee was more interested in becoming the center of attention than any English referee I’ve ever seen, even Clattenburg (with the single exception of Mike Dean, who should never be included in any comparison because he is so bad in so many ways he throws the scale off). After Salah’s goal, the referee pats the head of a City defender, to console him–I have never seen that before.

Mootilated

Are players allowed to be banned retroactively? For example, shouldn’t Ashley Young be banned for a game or two for his disgusting performance against Man City over the weekend? He deliberately handled the ball inside the box and almost snapped Aguero’s leg.

A Different George

If the referee saw the incident in question and chose not to issue a card (or issued a yellow rather than a red), then it cannot be reviewed, at least in England. If it took place out of the referee’s sight then, yes, there can be a retrospective ban; it has happened several times this season.

arsenal74

FA lenience just show how far we are from competing to PL title…would have this overturn been possible during Fergie-Wenger time 2000-2006? not a chance

santori

Some common sense at last. Ridiculous for Elneny to be punished for a common scuffle between players. If anything, we are somewhat fortunate Jack did not get penalised but Stephen’s actions warranted a straight red. Good to have Elneny BC if we say lose Granit to illness, Jack to a niggle, we will be out of sorts in midfield. Still the issue has ALWAYS been we (Wenger) have not done enough to provide for depth of quality in the engine room and this has more than anything-else cost us over last 3 or 4 seasons without Santi. Wenger continuously tries… Read more »

Teryima Adi

And for once the FA behaved.